PATH: “crowded cattle cars”


Attention PATH riders!

Below is an article from yesterdays NY Times. Their correspondent Billie Cohen’s objective in January was to write about the various commutes around the tri-state area.

This piece was in the Real Estate section (I guess to “educate” potential buyers in the New York area? To help real estate sales perhaps?)

Most of us already knew this, but she was surprised to find out that many folks didn’t live so close by, despite being on the PATH. It was just another leg in their long daily journey. What are your thoughts of her observations?

Next Stop: PATH Train From Hoboken…

8:02 a.m., Jan. 23 Wednesday.

path hoboken world trade center - PATH: "crowded cattle cars"

I had expected, perhaps swayed by optimistic real estate trend reports of the past few years, to see the Manhattan-bound PATH trains from Hoboken and Jersey City packed with young transplants who’d moved to the state’s urban enclaves for their affordability and up-and-coming status.

Conceivably my timing was off, or I wasn’t on the train that was shuttling those young Jersey urbanites, because most of the commuters I encountered actually lived farther out in New Jersey, and yes — despite all jokes to the contrary — they were happy to be living there. Even if it meant commuting in such crowded cattle cars.

Tiffany Harrington, a TV producer who lives in Plainfield, N.J., moved there 10 months ago from Piscataway, N.J., where she had been living at home. Now, instead of taking New Jersey Transit’s crowded Northeast Corridor train from Edison and then transferring to the subway, Ms. Harrington takes a different New Jersey Transit train to the PATH station at Journal Square in Jersey City, where she catches a train to Christopher Street in Manhattan. “My commute is actually a little bit cheaper now,” she said. “The change doesn’t bother me. The cost is less and I’m living on my own, so it all works out.”

Another commuter, Jodie Zales, was also new to the PATH train because of a recent move. Though she relocated to Hoboken from Union, N.J. I asked here why she didn’t move all of the way into the boroughs. “It’s cheaper than the city, a tad cheaper,” she said, adding, “I grew up in Jersey, so I’m a Jersey girl.”

path hoboken journal square - PATH: "crowded cattle cars"Since she works long hours as a production manager, Ms. Zales is a satisfied convert to the PATH, which is just one straight shot to her stop at 23rd Street. “As far as commuting, it’s a relief. I don’t have to worry about catching the last bus,” she said. “I also like Hoboken. I like having stores right at the corner. Of course, parking sucks.”

Other commuters I interrupted from their quick morning naps had ditched city life for greener backyards and bigger houses. Andrew Chan and his wife moved to West Orange, N.J., seven years ago from Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. “The main thing was housing. It was pretty inexpensive at that time and we wanted more room,” he said. The commute, he added, was an afterthought. “At the time, I didn’t think too much about it, but after we found a place, I looked at a few maps and talked to neighbors. We could take an express bus to the city, but it’s over $200 a month for one person.”

Instead, he opted for the PATH, which keeps costs down. He still has to drive to the Harrison station, and parking there has gone up in price. “Harrison used to have more affordable parking,” Mr. Chan said. “Now with development going on there, it’s about 50 percent more expensive than a year ago.” To save money, his wife drives him to the station.

Overall, it seemed like people living near PATH stations in New Jersey were most similar to commuters who take Metro-North trains. Those who resided closer to the city wanted to be near their jobs, and those who’d moved farther out wanted more space for their family.

Some observations: On both trains I took this morning there were more men than women. Do the wives all stay home in New Jersey, or work closer to their homes? Also, PATH trains have much more standing room than the subway, but there were fewer seats.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
22 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
17 Comment authors
homeworldmcspacebaroceanblooHansBrixRedstorm Recent comment authors
newest oldest

[quote comment=”64450″]I agree with the others – what a terrible piece of writing.

“Do the wives all stay home in New Jersey…?” Ummm, yeah. Women from NJ either stay home or don’t work in the city. Amazing how you were able to figure that out from one PATH ride, you genius!

I can’t believe the article made it to print.[/quote]

Are all NY Times “journalists” complete morons?


[quote comment=”64429″]After 11 or so, the train that comes in from NJ is the same one that comes back from 33rd st.

So no matter where you are, any train that comes in the station is the same one that you will be getting on in another 15 minutes anyway, ride to 33rd and get a seat at least.

I can’t believe no one else has figured this out. Amazing.[/quote]
I’ve been doing this for years.

oh, and why all this bitching about the smart cards?
I just get a metrocard instead. $10 gets you $12 0f credit on the card. that’s 8 rides on the path.


I agree with the others – what a terrible piece of writing.

“Do the wives all stay home in New Jersey…?” Ummm, yeah. Women from NJ either stay home or don’t work in the city. Amazing how you were able to figure that out from one PATH ride, you genius!

I can’t believe the article made it to print.


The $5 fee provides an incentive for people to use the same card over and over rather than flick it onto the tracks they’re done. If you lose it (and it’s registered) you will recover unused fare unlike quick cards. At least that’s my interpretation.

Besides, in the land of $12 cocktails and $400k studio apartments, will a one time $5 charge really kill you? Amortize it over 50 weeks at 10 trips/week it works out to one cent per trip.


The bigger scam is that you are now forced to use the smart cards…Oh by the way, we charge you $5 for the card…you have to love how they continue to fleece the public around here….