Hoboken soup and sandwich showdown

2/11/2008:

Today I take a look at three places in Hoboken and compare their “soup and sandwich” offerings. Taste and value will be the key factors in determining which wins the crown of “best” in town: The Original Soup Man, Panera Bread and The Turning Point.

Where is your favorite?

hoboken-soup-and-sandwich-showdown-review-hoboken411.jpg

Read the comparisons after the jump!

(Hoboken Soup & Sandwich Showdown – Continued…)

The premise is simple. Pick three places that have advertised soup and sandwich offers. The first choice was easy: Soup Man. I picked Panera Bread because I saw the sign on the table a few weeks ago, and Turning point because of their new $10 deal.

Original Soup Man

The Original Soup Man has plenty of comments. Some folks think it’s over-priced and won’t last. Others enjoy their concoctions.

For my meal, I chose the Chicken Chili and a 1/2 chicken panini wrap. Their offer comes with a drink, a piece of bread, one fruit and a tiny chocolate. The drinks were not any choice (for instance, I’d have to add $1.50 for a Sobe drink, instead of one of their teas or a bottle of Aquafina water.) I chose the water. I was also up-sold when they were filling my soup bowl. “Want some cheddar cheese with that?” I can’t refuse some cheddar, so I paid the extra $0.25. Total cost: $11.82

Taste: I enjoyed the sandwich, while on the petite side, it was very flavorful. The soup was very chunky and a smidge spicy. The tiny piece of bread helped add to the filling nature of the meal. I didn’t eat the fruit or chocolate. Save them for later.

hoboken-soup-man-soup-and-sandwich.JPG

Overall, not a bad value at a tad under 12 bucks. The soup did repeat on me after about an hour, and made me question the quality of the spices used.

Panera Bread

For some reason, I get the heebie jeebies in this place. Awkward layout, WAY too many strollers, and historically hit-or-miss on the meal quality. But the picture of the creamy tomato soup just piqued my interest and had to try it. Despite it being a “corporate chain,” they scored some bonus points today.

I got that, plus some kind of chicken sandwich again. The soup was extremely delicious (I have a thing for creamy tomato soup!) The sandwich didn’t get any negative points, but didn’t knock my socks off per se. I ate it a week ago, so my recollection is not so good. It also came with an apple or chips, and I chose the fruit again like a good boy. Beverage wasn’t included, only as an a la carte item. I went without. Total cost: $7.60.

panera-bread-hoboken-soup-sandwich.JPG

About 4 bucks cheaper than Soup Man (but no drink.) Even though I’m not comparing exact soups, I liked Panera’s better. So weigh your options: Annoying establishment vs. tasty tomato soup. I guess I’ll have to peek in next time to decide whether it’s worth it.

Turning Point

On paper, Turning Point “News Cafe” (not the restaurant, but the front part of the establishment – the one open from 6am to 10pm) deal sounds the best: $10 bucks gets you a cup of soup, a WHOLE sandwich, as well as one of their desserts!

Since the Turning point isn’t a soup specialty shop, there were less soups to choose from. I recall a Carrot Ginger, Clam Chowder, and a soup of the day (which was a turkey vegetable.) I chose the Carrot Ginger, plus a turkey sandwich on multi-grain bread. A rice-krispie treat was the dessert.

I was a bit nervous about the soup, because if it’s not a tomato-based soup, I usually chose a more chunky style dish. Manly soups are more my preference. However, this soup really was delicious. Not overwhelmed by ginger, and just the right amount of cream added. It was also sprinkled with some mint, which I couldn’t detect. It was refreshing and easy on the palette. Will I order it again? Maybe, if the soup of the day doesn’t reel me in.
turning-point-hoboken-soup-carrot-ginger.JPG
turning-point-hoboken-sandwich-turkey.JPG

My sandwich choice was OK. I have to remember that I don’t really enjoy sliced turkey like that anymore. After having it nearly every day I was in school when I was a kid, I realized that I out-grew it. Still very good. It comes with chips and salsa which is a bonus. But next time, I’m picking a different sammy. There were about 7 sandwich choices.

Overall, the cost was $10 + tax. The best overall value of the three, and enough so that Turning point receives the award for “Best Soup & Sandwich Spot” in Hoboken! Wasn’t an easy choice, because I liked Panera’s soup better. But getting more for your money, better views, were the winning factors.

Give it a shot before they end the special $10 promotion.

Leave a Reply

18 Comments on "Hoboken soup and sandwich showdown"

ilovepancakes
Member
ilovepancakes

bsrm: The Turning Point is on the corner of 14th and Sinatra Drive. Its in the shipyard! It’s convienent for me as I get off the ferry. There cafe which is the section that has the $10 deal is open till 9 at night, 7days

bsrm
Member
bsrm

I’ve never heard of Turning Point, where is it?

Colin
Member

[quote comment=”67501″]I wouldn’t dare get a sandwich in Hoboken from anything but a chain restaurant, since they tend to have corporate sanitation requirements. Every frickin mom-and-pop deli in Hoboken, the counter person slices the cold cuts into his/her bare hands, one slice at a time, and slaps each slice onto the sandwich. Even the filthiest falling-down bodegas in the worst parts of Brooklyn have to follow NY’s law against bare hand contact with ready to eat foods in the retail stores. They generally stick the sandwich under the slicer blade and slice the meat onto the sandwich, not onto their hands, even with the gloves.

Hot Bagels on 6th/Wash uses wax paper so they don’t touch the food so much. They also have 2 soups a day. I don’t think they have any combo deals, but a bagel sandwich is more than enough food for one meal.[/quote]

a few germs help keep your immune system up to what you need it to be. Have no fear!

Foster
Member

[quote comment=”67501″]I wouldn’t dare get a sandwich in Hoboken from anything but a chain restaurant, since they tend to have corporate sanitation requirements. Every frickin mom-and-pop deli in Hoboken, the counter person slices the cold cuts into his/her bare hands, one slice at a time, and slaps each slice onto the sandwich. Even the filthiest falling-down bodegas in the worst parts of Brooklyn have to follow NY’s law against bare hand contact with ready to eat foods in the retail stores. They generally stick the sandwich under the slicer blade and slice the meat onto the sandwich, not onto their hands, even with the gloves.

Hot Bagels on 6th/Wash uses wax paper so they don’t touch the food so much. They also have 2 soups a day. I don’t think they have any combo deals, but a bagel sandwich is more than enough food for one meal.[/quote]
**********
WOW! I can’t imagine living somewhere where I couldn’t grab a sandwhich at Vito’s (or you other favotire Mutz place), steak snadwhich at Zafra’s or Biggies, Bacon, egg and cheese at the General Store or the Cubano at La Isla. I can live a lifetime and never go into Subway or Quiznos, even if they do prepare everything with plastic gloves on…yuck!

elainetyger
Member
elainetyger

I wouldn’t dare get a sandwich in Hoboken from anything but a chain restaurant, since they tend to have corporate sanitation requirements. Every frickin mom-and-pop deli in Hoboken, the counter person slices the cold cuts into his/her bare hands, one slice at a time, and slaps each slice onto the sandwich. Even the filthiest falling-down bodegas in the worst parts of Brooklyn have to follow NY’s law against bare hand contact with ready to eat foods in the retail stores. They generally stick the sandwich under the slicer blade and slice the meat onto the sandwich, not onto their hands, even with the gloves.

Hot Bagels on 6th/Wash uses wax paper so they don’t touch the food so much. They also have 2 soups a day. I don’t think they have any combo deals, but a bagel sandwich is more than enough food for one meal.

wpDiscuz